This time, I read the support and service threads behind the plugin, as well as price and design. Fortunately, I cam across AP Instagram Feed Pro. The Pro version came with the options I was hunting for, had a fantastic price, and to top it all off, great customer support and service.
It only took a brief time to configure; and just like magic, my feed was back up. It is so amazingly flexible and clean! Below is my main streaming content and to the right, in the sidebare, my content via a hashtag.